Tennessee governor proposes statewide faculty voucher program

Join Chalkbeat Tennessee’s free day by day e-newsletter to maintain up with Memphis-Shelby County Colleges and statewide schooling coverage.

Gov. Invoice Lee proposed Tuesday to take Tennessee’s schooling voucher program statewide, beginning with as much as 20,000 college students who would get taxpayer cash subsequent faculty yr to attend a personal or residence faculty.

The Republican governor additionally known as for all Okay-12 college students to be eligible for vouchers starting in 2025.

Lee’s Schooling Freedom Scholarship Act, providing $7,075 yearly for every participant, would mark an enormous enlargement of eligibility for a voucher program that was billed as a pilot venture and is now in its second yr. The state’s schooling financial savings account program, which at the moment is proscribed to 3 city counties, has just below 2,000 enrollees.

Throughout an announcement in Nashville attended largely by lawmakers and allies, Lee mentioned statewide voucher eligibility was his imaginative and prescient for Tennessee throughout his first gubernatorial marketing campaign in 2018, when he known as for extra schooling decisions for fogeys.

“Dad and mom know what’s greatest for his or her baby because it pertains to schooling,” he mentioned, including that the vouchers would give all Tennessee households the liberty to decide on an excellent match, whether or not it’s in public, personal, parochial, or residence colleges.

His plan would finally remove revenue necessities and alter who may benefit from the vouchers. Quite than giving college students from low-income households a possibility to attend personal colleges — the unique acknowledged function of Lee’s schooling financial savings account program — the common vouchers Lee now proposes might additionally subsidize tuition prices for college kids from extra prosperous households who already attend personal colleges.

It’s unsure whether or not the ultimate laws would maintain personal or residence colleges accepting voucher cash to the identical accountability requirements that public colleges are topic to, together with testing necessities or the A-F letter grades that the state is making ready to offer out for the primary time in December.

“The ultimate particulars of this laws aren’t labored out,” Lee informed reporters after his announcement. “That is Day One. This might be a legislative effort.”

However Lee’s proposal will face a battle when the Common Meeting reconvenes in January. Even below a GOP supermajority, Tennessee’s voucher legislation squeaked by means of the Home of Representatives in 2019, after sponsors agreed to restrict this system to some city areas.

The open-ended value of common vouchers might be a problem in a state the place monetary consultants have warned lawmakers lately that Tennessee’s authorities wants to regulate spending in coming years. Lee mentioned his voucher proposal could be funded by means of a separate scholarship account, not the funding construction at the moment in place for public colleges, however he didn’t present a value evaluation.

Lee is attempting to journey the momentum of different states with Republican-controlled legislatures — together with Florida, Iowa, and Arkansas — that handed huge expansions of their voucher applications this yr amid mother or father anger over pandemic-era faculty closures and disagreements over what children are taught in public colleges.

Arkansas Gov. Sarah Huckabee Sanders, a fellow Republican who signed a legislation in March creating a faculty voucher program in her state, appeared on stage with Lee for his announcement. She heralded the work of their states as a part of a “conservative schooling revolution,” with vouchers as a centerpiece.

Extra vital for the legislative battle forward had been pledges Tuesday by Tennessee Home Speaker Cameron Sexton and Lt. Gov. Randy McNally to advance Lee’s voucher agenda. Sexton, a constitution faculty advocate and sure candidate for governor in 2026, voted in opposition to Lee’s schooling financial savings account invoice in 2019 and didn’t say why he now helps Lee’s proposal.

Nonetheless, the legislature’s Democratic leaders mentioned Lee and GOP management are in for a struggle — much like the one in Texas, the place a bipartisan coalition of Democrats and rural Republicans beat again Gov. Greg Abbott’s faculty voucher invoice this month throughout a particular legislative session.

Throughout a morning information convention, Tennessee Democrats charged that statewide vouchers will weaken public colleges and result in cuts in all the pieces from faculty personnel to arts and athletic applications, plus elevated property taxes for residents. They usually pledged to work throughout the aisle with Republican lawmakers who’ve been skeptical of vouchers from the outset.

“On the Home facet, we’re already reaching out to native officers to affix us in supporting public colleges,” mentioned Rep. John Ray Clemmons, a Nashville Democrat and Home caucus chairman, noting that public faculty districts are sometimes the most important employers within the state’s rural communities.

Democrats additionally warned that, below the governor’s plan, personal colleges will be capable to select the voucher college students they wish to settle for, particularly from households which are already certain for a personal schooling.

“What that is is a coupon program for wealthy households who don’t wish to pay the total worth of tuition,” mentioned Sen. London Lamar of Memphis, chief of the Senate Democratic caucus.

In the meantime, leaders of teams each for and in opposition to vouchers mentioned they had been mobilizing for the struggle forward.

Among the many pro-voucher contingent is People for Prosperity in Tennessee, a part of a conservative community backed by the billionaire Koch brothers, and the American Federation for Youngsters, whose founding chairperson was Michigan billionaire Betsy DeVos.

Teams opposing Lee’s plan embody the state’s two largest skilled organizations for educators, the Tennessee Schooling Affiliation and Skilled Educators of Tennessee.

Tennessee has been a battleground state within the faculty selection motion, with a coalition of conservative political organizations utilizing out-of-state cash to marketing campaign in opposition to incumbent lawmakers who oppose vouchers.

Lee’s latest proposal, if authorised, would put Tennessee on observe to develop into the tenth state to undertake a common voucher program, becoming a member of Arizona, Ohio, Oklahoma, North Carolina, and West Virginia. However the change would occur earlier than state officers have sufficient information to guage the effectiveness of its present schooling financial savings account program, which launched final yr in Davidson and Shelby counties and this yr in Hamilton County.

For the 2024-25 faculty yr, Lee proposes to offer 10,000 “scholarships” for college kids who’re thought of economically deprived, have a incapacity, or are eligible for Tennessee’s present schooling financial savings account program. One other 10,000 would go to a common pool of scholars throughout the state.

Starting in 2025-26, Tennessee would provide vouchers to any Okay-12 scholar.

A one-page promotional doc circulated by the governor workplace mentioned Tennessee would prioritize “at the moment enrolled college students, low-income and public faculty college students if demand exceeds accessible funding.”

For years, Tennessee has been within the backside tier of states in funding public schooling and stays within the backside half nationally, even with a $1 billion improve this yr as a part of Lee’s overhaul of Tennessee’s schooling funding components.

In 2020-21, earlier than the newest funding, nationwide information ranked the state thirty seventh for per-student funding. And in its annual grades for schooling funding, the Schooling Regulation Heart gave Tennessee two F’s for funding degree and energy, and a D for funding distribution.

Marta Aldrich is a senior correspondent and covers the statehouse for Chalkbeat Tennessee. Contact her at maldrich@chalkbeat.org.